Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Marcus Fabius Quintilianus does a reverse one and a half somersaults with three and a half twists, pike, in his grave

Mr. LATIMER: The president had taken a class at Yale about how to write a speech, and I forgot who the professor was, but there was a very strict way that we were supposed to do all the speeches - and I was told this a number of times when I came to the White House. And the Yale school of speechwriting was: you give an introduction, Point A, Point B, Point C, a prayeration(ph), and a conclusion.

GROSS: A prayeration is what? What's a prayeration?

Mr. LATIMER: I was just going to say I'm from Michigan, so you know, I never heard the word prayeration before. I didn't know. I think it's a summary of what the points were or something.


Shadows:

Matt Latimer: A speechwriter for George W. Bush. From Michigan.

Gross: Fresh Air personage. Full transcript of interview.

Quintilian: a Roman rhetorician, author of Institutio Oratoria, who knew from peroration.

Labels: , , , , ,

Monday, September 21, 2009

The best parody is the thing itself


David Weinberger detects a certain closeness between a 2004 parody of RIAA impropaganda and, hooha, a new piece of genuine RIAA bullshit.


Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Big Mac Panic Attack

Peter Overby at NPR:
Fannie and Freddie have kept their profiles high because of their odd situation: They're not government agencies, but they're not regular corporations either. As government sponsored enterprises, or GSEs, they're often thought to have guarantees of federal support. It lets them get discounts when they borrow money.

To maintain that advantage and others, they hire well-placed politicos for big salaries.

A rival lobbyist once described Fannie Mae as a political organization that happened to be in the mortgage business.

Italics added.

What Overby, a very sharp reporter, is describing could be termed a "rhetorical object." This is not the guarantee of the federal government, but the appearance of that guarantee, the promise of a promise. The underlying blurry charter, history, and function of the Macs depend on the actions of a market that is constantly in need of being persuaded that something that could be true, or could just as well be illusory. Its status is constantly being contested and depends not upon a legal determination but upon the greasification of certain surprisingly august palms.

According to The Center for Investigative Reporting, the gaggle of palms, a distributed chorus of hortatory specialists, includes the likes of James A Johnson, Louis J. Freeh, Rahm Emanuel, Susan Molinari and more who work to maintain this state of affairs because upon its undecided status rests a good portion of their income as well as a considerable portion of their juice:

In the first three months of the year alone, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac spent a combined total of about $3.5 million on lobbying and hired 42 outside firms.

If the object that undergirds so much of the housing, lending, and credit industry worldwide indeed is rhetorical in nature, rather than stable, fixed, and "guaranteed," it might be useful in public discussion to acknowledge this, rather than proceed as if the question of the Big Macs' promise were, in the reductive sense alone, rhetorical.

Update: Another take at Gifthub.

Labels: , , , , ,

Friday, July 11, 2008

I got my Quintilian exercise thru the New York Times

Let's see now. Today's New York Times says

Loan-Agency Woes Swell From a Trickle to a Torrent

In the beginning was the word:
The word began spreading...
inches go by, lined with journalistic cliches offering what is most accurately described as a phantasm - "tumult" "plunging," the cliched trickle "has suddenly become a torrent" ...

All by way of exordium. That's the part of the oration that is designed to capture attention.

Finally, a few inches down, the hooha - the nut graf - the narratio the place where we learn what's at the root of all this viral panic:
What set off this storm, and what happens next?

The cause of this week’s huge declines remains somewhat unclear.
Having been treated to a personification of Rumor, we learn that Charles Duhigg does not know its basis. Mr. Duhigg is the Times employee typing the vivid portrait. He has a Harvard MBA. He proceeds to the confirmatio - the advancement of proofs. "The appeal to logos is emphasized here," says Quintilian. Mr. Duhigg weaves concatenations of mights and coulds and woulds:
  • 5 mights
  • 5 coulds
  • 7 woulds
In one graf, he niftily manages one should, three coulds and a would:
Should that happen again, Fannie and Freddie could suspend buying some loans — which could bring much of the American housing economy to a standstill. Or the companies could continue doing business, but losing money on many of their deals, which would continue to undermine investors’ confidence in the stocks.
Mr. Duhigg doesn't offer much in the way of reprehensio - the bit where you knock down opposition to your figment:

Opposition:
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, for their parts, say such talk is dangerous. Both companies say they have capital on hand that exceeds what is required by their regulator.
Mr. Duhigg's reprehensio:
But people are still worried.
His case - of journaljism - is strong. He buggers off with a quick peroratio, quoting a fearful Florida legislator (Mel Martinez) rather than offering some authorial statement:
“All we can do sometimes is grab on and hope we don’t get thrown off the ride.”

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

FASTForward to Serendip (FF pt. 4)


"We have all become revolutionaries," said FAST ceo John Markus Lervik at the start of FASTForward08. This note was echoed by several speakers at the conference:
  • Enterprise 2.0 will challenge monolithic corporate structures, said "Wikinomics" author Don Tapscott.
  • "Corporations are going out of business at an accelerating rate," noted John Hagel, adding that average life of S&P 500 corporations has declined by 80% over the past 70 years and today averages 15 years.
  • For JP Rangaswami of BT, power placed in consumers' hands is a major driver roiling the formerly more placid outlook of large stratified corporations.
The elephant-in-the-room is not exempt:
After starting the year near the $700 mark, Google shares have shed about one-third of their value. The stock slipped more than 8% in the past two days following the release of data from comScore that showed a decline in the growth rate of so-called "paid clicks," which takes place when Web users click on an ad-supported link. Marketplace
Only 1/3 of user queries scurrying across the web bother to go through web search engines, said IDC's Sue Feldman in her keynote. Once you've established a relationship with a gateway, hub or node, says Feldman, there's no need for the sort of search Google offers.

Which is where FAST and other companies come in. Beyond the $3 billion market Google has largely cornered via quick search + advertising, says FAST's Zia Zaman, there's another two to four billion market that will grow through advanced search and the monetization thereof.

So we'll take a peak here into advanced search and in a further post offer a similar glimpse of monetization.

Search is not changing something: it’s changing everything - JM Lervik


The claim for advanced search as the next big thing -- as far as I could make out from listening to the speakers at the conference, and talking with some of the analysts and vendors -- is in its ability to get to know the user, anticipate his/her wants and needs, and intervene with relevant information sensitive to the intent of the user and to the context in which the search is afoot.

Michael Cleary of Reuters spoke to Jerry Michalski about fusing user intent and advanced search content. Somewhat more elaborately, Zaman spoke of FAST's developing art of "interaction management," leading to a flexible, personalized mode of search built around the uniqueness of the individual user.

Rapidly ticking off four attributes of the new technology, Zaman told analysts and bloggers that search
  • connects my world
  • translates to my terms
  • understands what I need
  • finds what I want
It's a bold claim, made bolder when he notes that via a mode of "conversation" with the seeker, search will not only find what the seeker was looking for, but via the power of serendipity, change your decision by discovering "something you didn't know you needed."


There's a rich, suggestive tonality to these descriptions, reminiscent of the language of quest romance and psychoanalysis. More than an algorithm, what's being described is a deus ex machina probing the subterranean desires of the seeker even as he explores the web (rather than surfing it) to discover that which he doesn't yet know he wants.

It's as if search has undergone a profound augmentation. No longer is it simply and matter of factly, "seek and ye shall find," a la Google. Now, and moreso in the coming time, the "user" is on a quest, but in the course of the quest, he or she discovers what there is to seek. Search 2.0 = search squared, the turning of the explorative intelligence of IT upon the aura, the trace, the smudge of the seeker in the interactive slipstream.

If that's what's on offer, how does it work? Because let's face it, this isn't easy to do, as Zaman himself made clear when he told us, "It is terribly difficult to get at the true intent of the user."

For a hint, let's return to our friends at Lexalytics who shared some of their techniques with us the other day.

Unstructured search analyzes all sorts of information, however messy. It can locate and purports to assess the sentiment and tone of massive amounts of information.

According to Brian Pinette and Tim Mohler at Lexalytics, the art of sensing the tone of articles relies at least in part on algorithms that suss out emotive or value-laden words and relate them to nearby entities, persons or companies or products, with methods that distinguish which entities are being described or judged.

I was curious how the analysis could be certain that the words it was sensing belonged to the author of the document. Say, for example, there's a movie review in which the reviewer quotes another writer who loved the same film he's writing about. That encapsulated review presumably would glow with positive terms; but say it is within the reviewer's own strongly negative review -- same movie, two patches of words sharply differing in sentiment. What then?

That falls under the problem of anaphora, Pinette explained. Not the rhetorical kind, but the linguistic variety, defined as: coreference of one expression with its antecedent. The antecedent provides the information necessary for the expression’s interpretation. (link)

E.g., Mr. Defamer said he hated the film would be anaphoric in that it is relatively simple for us to carry the identify "Mr. Defamer" forward to be picked up by the pronoun, "he." Of course taken in isolation it's impossible to be sure that Mr. Defamer is not speaking about his friend Mr. Carp's view of the film, or for that matter, his dentist Dr. Scheissfinger's opinion of something found on his, Mr. Defamer's, front teeth. Then there's problematic anaphora.

Pinette said anaphora is a challenge but appeared confident it will be mastered -- along with cataphora, endophora, and the like. The rules of grammar and logic, while complex, seem after all to obey the rule of rules. But what, I wondered, of metaphor-a?

I was intrigued partly because the more complex texts, essays or literary forays that include not simply reported speech but implied speakers and the full panoply of rhetorical devices -- the stuff of rhetorical analysis which as a comparatist I used to do -- would appear to offer yet greater challenges. I suggested to Pinette that there might be in the forest of rhetorical terms some useful means of describing various linguistic structures. Whether they would help sort out the elusive, polysemous turns of sense flowing through sentences, chapters, or books remains to be seen.

Beyond the question of computing the reading of content --of sentiment, tone, and figurative speech -- is the question of sounding the intent of the seeker. How do you give him the thing he didn't know he was looking for? The kettles of fish this borders on -- questions of intentionality, meaning, the nature of mind and intelligence -- are likely to require more than the isle of Serendip.


More later

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,